 A
Murder, A Mystery, and A Marriage

By MARK TWAIN
Reviewed by
Kenny Brechner
The news that a long lost manuscript,
penned by a famous dead author, has been unearthed cannot fail to excite
interest and romantic speculation amongst that author's readership.
The last decade has seen a number of
instances in this regard, Jules Verne's Paris in the Twentieth Century,
and Louisa May Alcotts' A Modern Mephistopheles, for example, which have
rewarded readers' expectations handsomely by virtue of possessing both literary
and historical interest.
No one could question the wisdom of
publishing Verne's Paris in the Twentieth Century, rejected 140 years ago
as being too bizarre to publish, Verne had in fact brilliantly anticipated fax
machines, photocopiers, urban light pollution, populist trends in academia, and
a host of other modern realities.
Not all literary resurfacings are as happy
as Verne's however, and a number of questions arise therefore. What of a
manuscript which lacks literary merit and quality? Is historical interest
sufficient in itself? What if the author and or the author =s
estate purposely suppressed it?
We come thus to one of the most highly
touted new releases of the fall season, Mark Twain's A Murder, A Mystery, and
a Marriage. Written 125 years ago Twain composed A Murder, A Mystery, and
a Marriage , between his masterpieces, Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry
Finn. A so called ABlind
Novellete@
Twain conceived of the manuscript as the basis of a competition in which he
would challenge the nation=s
leading authors, Henry James for example, to write alternate endings.
The competition never occurred, the story
was never published, and the manuscript was widely believed to be lost. When it
resurfaced the Twain estate successfully blocked its publication in 1949, but in
2000 the right to publish the manuscript was acquired by the library to which
Twain had initially donated it.
The reader is immediately aware why the
Twain estate blocked the manuscript's publication. Even Roy Blount Jr., who
wrote a detailed Foreward and Afterward for this first edition, cannot refrain
from asking, "what was bugging Mark Twain in 1876 to make him think up the
benighted village of Deer Lick?" And again, "The reader may also be
wondering why the whole story is marked by ill (in more than one sense)
humor."
Taken by itself A Murder, A Mystery,
and a Marriage is a joyless sketch of a squalid rural town whose primary
purpose is to serve as a setup for a self righteous and ill considered diatribe
against Jules Verne, of all people, who had died shortly before A Murder, A
Mystery, and a Marriage was composed. Twain seems to have taken up a
loathing for Verne on the grounds that Verne embellished other people's
adventures in his book.
Given Twain =s
aggressive scruples one can only wonder what he would have thought of a
publisher=s
decision to aggressively market a book to the general public which can have
interest only to Twain scholars, thereby exploiting Twain=s
good name for profit, whilst giving his legacy a black eye in return.
|
|